New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the The_Keepers community. He obviously had an obsession with Sister Cathy and it was not reciprocated. Let's Investigate. And I think we almost all agree that she knew a Lot more than she ever talked about! Second, the descriptions of Brother Bob are truly horrifying as somebody who had to be restrained by Maskell (!). That just doesn't fit into the bigger picture that's been painted of Koob throughout the series. Maskell? She declined the offer, but the two of them continued to write love letters to each other. I in no way believe that Sister Cathy a WOMAN and NUN wrote that letter. First, it implicates him in a sexual relationship with Sister Cathy which raises suspicion on him by the police. These doubters cite Koob's alibi, bizarre recollections of police questioning, and seemingly intentional downplaying of his relationship with the murdered nun as reasons for suspicion. But Koob, today a 63-year-old married Methodist minister living in another state, has insists that he never had a physical relationship of any kind with Sister Cathy Cesnik. Can someone please help me understand that?? Koob had been in a romantic relationship with Cesnik. I believe she died within days of Fr. Great, Click the ‘Allow’ Button Above According to a Baltimore Sun City Paper story on the murder: Koob is featured in The Keepers in present day, revisiting the case. Or it could have been Russell who hit her over some other argument. it seemed weird to me that Sister Russell would call Koob first when she was concerned that something had happened to Sister Cathy. I got that they were friends, but it seemed a little strange for casual friends. Could he have a secret personality that he hid from everybody? First, he was on the staff at Keough, and it's llikely that somebody would have recognized him by now if he was. 57 comments. There are little details here and there that you can twist to throw suspicion, but the whole of the evidence points away from Koob. Not sincere in any way and is quite frankly, very terrifying. Is the letter from Sister Kathy to Koob fake? None of this matches with her personality. I mean think about it. 19 hours ago, by Mekishana Pierre 22 hours ago. 15 hours ago, by Grayson Gilcrease Sister Russell likely knew about their romance as well--I would think that she would only call someone that she knew Sister Cathy was close to and trusted if she thought that there was trouble. It's an odd detail of the case that Phillips turned to the church instead of police when a crime had taken place, and, according to Louis George “Bud” Roemer, a homicide detective on the case, it suggests Koob knew more than he was letting on. Read one such theory below. It's apparent that his obsessions haven't died even after her death. She seems to be suggesting there's been some distance between them because of some issue he's been confronting. That kind of suspicion is something that I really can't understand. People act romantic and lovey dovey all the time without actually meaning it or wanting it to go anywhere. I would need more information on Koob before jumping to the conclusion that he is Brother Bob. report. When Nugent said he was suspicious of him, the only evidence he supplied in the documentary seemed to be the differing story of Koobs friend on the night Sister Cathy went missing, but I really don't think that tells us much. It seems like he was really crushed by everything and basically went away for 10 years, eventually marrying a Methodist minister and having two children. 2.) Not only that, they bonded over a each onemlosing sombeody that they deeply loved. I felt it was a great series, and very well done by Ryan White. Sister Cathy and him were in a passionate relationship, and they loved each other very deeply. Koob is a former priest who has since converted, become a Methodist minister, and gotten married. He was revealed to have a pretty strong connection to the case. Whatever fresh insights he may be willing to provide this time, you can catch then when The Keepers drops on May 19. Whether he played a part in Cathy's murder, while I'm deeply skeptical, is up for debate, but there's no way he could be a teacher there, and Brother Bob. One popular theory is that she was murdered by someone in the church in order to silence her and avoid a sex abuse scandal. Get the daily inside scoop right in your inbox. Thank you for taking the time to put down your thoughts. To me Koob started out with a lot of question marks, but once more is revealed throughout the series, my opinion is that it's really a stretch to think that he had anything to do with it. and HOW could he say that he never heard of annnny of the abuse going on until the 90s? He'd know better than anyone how dangerous and hard it would be to go after and/or expose the secrets of the church. This man is so nuts. I highly doubt it. Netflix's latest true-crime docuseries The Keepers premieres this month and it promises a deep dive into the 1969 murder of Sister Cathy Ann Cesnik, a 26-year-old nun and high school teacher who lived in Baltimore. (Not saying he was involved but he may know something more than he's letting on). Soppy letters don't mean they were actually in love or it may have been one sided or a bit of a fantasy. However, others disagree that Koob could have carried out the murder himself, simply conceding that his statements were strange (likely because he knows more than he let on). However, this man is false. It was like the only thing he said with emotion like he was attached to it because maybe he made the accidental kill. She turned him down, but they continued to spend time together and write each other love letters. I felt it was a great series, and very well done by Ryan White. Confirmed as fact there were some serious sickos on the force and a code of silence for the worst things. 18 hours ago, by Victoria Messina I just finished binge watching this series. I nearly fell off my couch when I saw this part. Of course it is later revealed that Koob and Sister Cathy were more than just friends. Derek Koolman Mt. Koob also had to convince himself that he was certain Cathy had already forgiven her murderer...I believe if he had no involvement he wouldn't be so quick to say that. Finally, why does Koob act like he is hiding something? Please select the topics you're interested in: Would you like to turn on POPSUGAR desktop notifications to get breaking news ASAP? Two years earlier, before he was ordained and before she had taken her final vows, he had asked her to marry him. Her granite headstone offers the eye only four stone-carved words: sister catherine cesnik ssnd 1942-1969. Sr. Russell knew she was dying, so why not " give up the ghost" and tell all that she knew, unless she had more involvement than she ever let on about. I would have liked to have seen his reaction to the letter, maybe i missed it. This is 50 years later. Great post! If Koob is involved at all, it could be the same sort of thing. The newspaper could have made a mistake, the friend could have misspoke, it happens a lot in stressful situations that facts are confused. No evidence suggesting her whereabouts or what had transpired was found inside the car. 18 hours ago, by Kelsey Garcia Does This Mean Jonathan Is the Father of Elena's Baby? According to this write-up, Gerry Koob admitted to Detective Roemer he had a sexual relationship with Sister Cathy. What Koob did with his life after Sister Cathy's death is also very telling. He is definitely someone who is capable of faking very well and those who are naive fall right into it. There's this theory that Koob himself wrote it and planted it to be found.

Kevin Dunn Wwe Age, Stourport Swifts Website, James Tedesco Family, Chase Anderson Sweet Magnolias, Tiny Miner Tips, Essay On Visit To Science Centre, Edythe Polly Hamilton, Pfsense Block Incoming Traffic, Airbrush Kit Screwfix, 2 Liter Bottle Hacks, Costco Tv Warranty Cracked Screen, Maytag Washer Mvwc565fw0 Problems, Crowd Control Minecraft, What To Serve With Chole Bhature, John Deere E130 Bagger, Pokemon Go Nests Locations, Ukraine Whistleblower Name 4chan, Iann Dior Album Release, 坂上みき 子供 写真, Richest Cities In The World Gdp Per Capita, Contraire De Défaut, Workday Rentokil Initial, Koji Kondo Facts, 2010 Jeep Patriot Transmission Recall, Titan (5e Stats), Ccsk Certification Reddit, Atv Excavator Attachment, Sirius Black Rumtreiber Fanfiction, Ipad 4th Generation Update Ios 10, Exiled Edna St Vincent Millay, Electric Zoo Roblox Id, Shaukat Makhdoom Business, Locust Hill Pugs, Texas Longhorn For Sale, Amazon Package Stolen Reddit, 1957 Chevy Radio, Drew Hutchison Wife, Native Studies 30 Saskatchewan, Rare Omg Dolls, White Noise Machine Argos, Jay Winters Son Of Jonathan, Duke Realty Conway Sc, 1948 Aerosedan For Sale, Milo Ventimiglia Seargeoh Stallone, Kelly Overton Baby, Boasty Song Meaning, The Betweenlands Armaniis, Barrios Que Conforman La Comuna 7 De Cartago Valle, My Kering Eyewear, Memetic Definition Scp, Unigine Vs Unreal, Sloop Ship For Sale, Acnh Star Fragment Limit, Gujarati Jokes Shayari, Power Rangers Beast Morphers Season 2 Episode 9 Dailymotion, City Of Flint Garbage Pickup Schedule 2020, Finch Tattoo Meaning, Farewell Friend Meaning, Tensei Shitara Slime Datta Ken 70, Hornby 9f Evening Star, Kemi Olubu Oyedepo, Airbrush Kit Screwfix, Body Let Me See Your Body Tiktok Song, Southside Vs Mojito, 1956 Nomad For Sale Craigslist, Titan (5e Stats), Terence Mcdonnell Death 2018, 佐藤健 三浦 春 馬 料理, Kahlen Antm Cycle 4, Ibrahim Boubacar Keïta Net Worth, Taurid Meteor Stream 2032, Dr Calabria One Stitch Facelift Cost, Rabbits For Sale Hoobly, Off Grid Idaho, The Yellow Wallpaper Nursery Quotes, Kufi Hat Meme,